One of my favorite bloggers, Kit over at Keep It Trill wrote about the new Yale study that states what we all know to be true: that roughly half of college educated black women will never get married or have children. She cites this fact, along with abortion to make her argument that cultural forces which helped white women are acting as a sort of “genocide lite” for black people. Please note that this is a very simplistic summary of her views, so you really should read her post in order to understand where she’s coming from on that. Very Smart Brothas explored a similar argument a couple of weeks ago, wondering if the black middle class would render itself extinct.
I myself have briefly explored how the choice to be a housewife has become controversial, as well as why many educated black women are still single. But it wasn’t until I began to comment on Kit’s post that I managed to consolidate my views in a more coherent way. She suggested that I write a post on it and I had some time on my hands, so here goes.
The feminist movement and all the changes that came with it–full access to contraceptives, legalized abortion, women’s ability to choose to work outside the home–were radically different than anything Western society had ever seen before. In all of my studies in history and sociology, I have never heard of a society besides ours in the 20th century, in which both parents worked outside the home. Societies are either matriarchal or patriarchal. Egalitarianism exists only in the sense that men’s and women’s roles are valued equally, not in the sense that men and women can do the same things. I have always maintained that God made men and women different for a reason, and that we are better off when both genders perform the tasks that they are naturally best suited to do. This flies in the face of
Now, feminism hasn’t affected white women too adversely because whites on average have a higher socioeconomic status. When a white couple gets married, it is likely that their parent paid for all or most of the wedding–hence they are not starting their life in debt. Furthermore, both parties are likely to be the beneficiaries of intergenerational wealth, which equals increased social mobility.* Getting a job isn’t a problem when daddy owns a company. Or it could just be that their parents are well enough off to have created a trust fund with which to pay for their children’s education. We must also consider that wealthy people have life insurance, and thus when they die their children don’t have to pay for the funeral and can receive an inheritance. Even if this inheritance is only $2000, the advantage incurred by each generation compounds. The second part of this scenario is that white women did not need to work outside the home. They simply fought for the right to work if they wanted to. So when a white woman starts juggling a career with her family and realizes that it’s too hard, she can become a housewife without qualms because the family doesn’t need her income to survive. Conversely, the precarious position of blacks in America meant that black women were working outside the home long before Susan B. Anthony was a glimmer in her daddy’s eye. Black women wanted to be able to pursue more lucrative work in order to help their husbands, who were often put out of work because they seemed dangerous (because we all know black men are just one step away from unleashing their primitive, beast-like urges**) or because immigrants would do the work cheaper.
After suffering under the twin oppressions of racism and sexism for so long, black women were thrilled to be able to rise to their potential. Since they were less threatening than their male counterparts and filled two diversity quotas to boot, they rapidly found success in higher education as well as the boardroom and eventually outpaced black men. So now we’re in a depressing situation where it seems all the “eligible” black men want anything but a black woman, and so we must all fight over the remaining few.
It’s unfortunate, but women can’t have it all. Men can’t have it all either–it’s just that they long ago accepted that in pursuing career success to provide for their families they would not be the primary caretaker in their children’s lives. Women feel guilty for being away from their children because we are biologically programmed to be nurturers. Matriarchal societies function because the women do all the important work but the men stay at home with the kids, so women don’t have to feel guilty.
So basically, if you are a black woman and you want to get an education and get married, you must date with intention. You don’t have time to waste on “friends with benefits” or other dead end relationships. It may sound frivolous, but I went off to college fully intending to obtain my B.S. and my MRS. My mother told me that once I left college/grad school, I would never again be around such a large pool of eligible bachelors with similar qualifications who are open to getting married. And survey says that she was right. You have to find someone to grow with, because once men finish school, they are content to spend the next 10 years building material wealth and will marry a younger (translation: more fertile) woman to build a family with. And young men don’t marry older women (again, it doesn’t make biological sense) so after 35 there really is a man shortage.
Finally, my last point: it’s not degrees that scare men off but bad attitudes. Don’t believe the hype, any man worth his salt wants a woman who has more to offer than a pretty face. Men want to be stimulated physically, emotionally and mentally. The problem is that black women have gotten so used to doing for themselves that it’s hard for them to cede the power in the relationship, and they will worry, nag and browbeat a man until all the fight’s gone out of him. There are certain universal truths about men that will make life a lot easier for women if they only accept it…but I’ll save that for the next installment.
There was a lot to chew on in this post so I know my readers have something to say…let me know what’s on your mind!
**In case you didn’t know, I was being sarcastic.